Glassdoor Exposed: The Truth Behind Company Reviews in 2024
The market conditions make many professionals turn to employer review platforms like Glassdoor for insights into potential employers.
However, recent trends suggest that these once-trusted platforms may no longer provide the unbiased information job seekers need.
Here's what you need to know to make informed career decisions in 2024:
The Erosion of Transparency
While Glassdoor was originally designed to offer candid employee feedback, many companies have found ways to manipulate their profiles. This can include:
Flooding the site with positive reviews, often on the same day
Removing or burying negative reviews
Incentivizing current employees to leave glowing feedback
As a result, the overall ratings and reviews may not accurately reflect the true employee experience.
According to a 2023 study by the Journal of Management, 68% of HR professionals admitted to actively managing their company's online reputation on review platforms.
This highlights the growing challenge of finding authentic employee feedback.
Red Flags to Watch For
When evaluating a company on Glassdoor, be alert for these warning signs:
An unusually high number of 5-star reviews posted in a short timeframe
Overly generic positive reviews with little specific detail
A sudden improvement in ratings without a clear explanation
Very few or no recent negative reviews for large organizations
Dr. John Vlastelica, CEO and Founder of Recruiting Toolbox, emphasizes:
"The quality of your candidate pool is a direct reflection of the quality of your hiring process."
This underscores the importance of looking beyond surface-level reviews to understand a company's true culture and practices.
Beyond Glassdoor: Effective Research Strategies
To get a more accurate picture of a potential employer, consider these approaches:
Reach out to former employees on LinkedIn for candid feedback
Look for patterns in reviews across multiple platforms, not just Glassdoor
Pay attention to how the company responds to negative reviews
Research the company's financial health and recent news
Ask probing questions about culture and employee experience during interviews
A 2024 Forbes report reveals that 86% of job seekers research company reviews and ratings before deciding where to apply.
This statistic underscores the critical need for thorough, multi-faceted research when evaluating potential employers.
💡Check out my ultimate Job Interview Cheat Sheet for more tips on landing your next job faster.
The Importance of Due Diligence
While online reviews can provide valuable insights, they should never be your sole source of information about a potential employer.
Take the time to thoroughly research companies, leveraging multiple sources and your professional network.
Jeff Moore, VP of Talent Acquisition at Toast, advises:
"Never forget that behind every resume is a person who deserves respect and consideration throughout the hiring process."
This human-centric approach should extend to how we evaluate potential employers as well.
💡For guidance on transitioning to a customer success career, explore my Customer Success Career Guide.
Moving Forward
Adapt to the changing landscape of employer review sites.
Approaching these platforms with healthy skepticism and supplementing their information with additional research will help you make more informed career decisions.
Kelly Jones, CPO at Cisco, emphasizes the importance of continuous growth:
"Allowing teams to learn and grow is key to success. As recruiters, we have the power to enable personal and professional development, which ultimately leads to individual and organizational growth."
Stay vigilant, ask tough questions, and trust your instincts when evaluating potential employers.
Your career is too important to base on potentially manipulated data.
💡For more insights on customer success career development, check out my Customer Success Manager Skills Guide.
I hope that helps,
-Hakan.